torque.news Subscribe
LOADS OF QUESTIONS, photo 1-0
LOADS OF QUESTIONS, photo 1-1
LOADS OF QUESTIONS, photo 1-2
LOADS OF QUESTIONS, photo 1-3

LegislationHeavyTorque 48Pages 18–23

LOADS OF QUESTIONS

Peter McKenna examines how the collapse of West Midlands police’s mobile-crane prosecutions has sharpened concerns over abnormal-load enforcement, escort charging and consistency across UK forces

Words PETER MCKENNA

HeavyTorque 48Pages 18–19

What had been listed last week as a two-day test trial concluded in under three hours. West Midlands Police (WMP) had brought prosecutions against mobile-crane operators, alleging overweight loads following breaches of police-imposed embargo times. The prosecution offered no evidence, and all four defendants were acquitted. This week, WMP withdrew the remaining non-test cases, in a sweeping setback.

Credit is due to James Edes (inset, left) of Dyne Solicitors and barrister Richard Dawson (inset, right) of Lincoln House Chambers, who secured an excellent result for their clients and, by extension, the wider mobile-crane industry. But a case collapsing so completely, so quickly, after months of prosecutions against more than 60 operators raises a wider question: how did it get this far, and what does it say about abnormal-load enforcement?

It would be tempting to treat the collapse as a single overzealous prosecution that failed under scrutiny. The evidence, however, points to something more structural.

The Construction Plant-hire Association (CPA), representing a 2,000-strong membership of plant hire and heavy haulage firms, has been explicit. In a statement earlier this year, it described WMP as “a national outlier”, accused the force of treating notifications “as if they require approval” and said operators were being pushed towards paid escorts where self-escorting would be accepted elsewhere in the UK.

The CPA’s member survey underlined the impact: more than 80% of respondents reported operational disruption, two-thirds reported serious project delays and one in six faced extra costs above £100,000. Many are now rerouting simply to avoid the force’s area altogether.

Police motorcycle with WIDE LOAD sign gesturing to stop as Scania truck carries large boat through town
Three police motorcycles with WIDE LOAD signs parked on rainy verge while escort crew work nearby
Police officer in high‑visibility jacket photographing lineup of police motorcycles and marked cars on motorway
The rest of this feature

Sign in to keep reading, free

Sign in for 3 free features a week, mixed across all three magazines. Already a subscriber, or want this issue on its own? Those work too.

Sign in Get the digital pass · £28.00/year
Buy this issue · £7.95

Also in issue 48

The whole issue